Techno-Solutionism

Research · Ongoing

Can technology solve our social and environmental problems? This strand of research is a critical assessment of the promise and pitfalls of turning to technology — and to AI in particular — for sustainable development. It combines conceptual work on techno-fixes and techno-solutionism with frameworks for evaluating the environmental, social and governance (ESG) impacts of AI.

The work began with the edited volume Technology and Sustainable Development (Routledge, 2023), which grew out of the Technology & Sustainable Futures network, and continues through the TSF conference series.

Featured Article

Technological Remedies for Social Problems

Defining and Demarcating Techno-Fixes and Techno-Solutionism

Science and Engineering Ethics, 30(6), article 60, 2024 · Open Access

Can technology resolve social problems by reducing them to engineering challenges? In the 1960s, Alvin Weinberg answered yes, popularizing the term “techno-fix” in the process. The concept was immediately criticized and over time evolved into a disparaging term. Despite extensive criticism, both “techno-fix” and “techno-solutionism” remain ill-defined concepts. In this article, we provide more precise definitions and clearly distinguish between techno-fixes and techno-solutionism through conceptual engineering.

Read the Article →

Key concepts

The article proposes the following definitions (Sætra & Selinger, 2024):

Techno-fix
“A techno-fix is a technological remedy for a social problem that only involves minimal use of political power or economic incentives to change an individual’s behavior and does not require changing social norms.”
Solutionism
“Solutionism is a way of thinking about social problems. It is characterized by confidence in human reason and our capacity to find and implement numerous strategies for overcoming obstacles and capitalizing on opportunities, typically through courses of action that significantly alter social norms.”
Techno-solutionism
“Techno-solutionism is a technology-driven approach to solutionism. It is rooted in Promethean optimism about the revolutionary potential of science and engineering.”

The distinction turns on a simple question: is technology used to address a problem without requiring people to change their behaviour, or to build new and better societies in which social norms and habits are themselves targets of technological intervention? Techno-fixes are, in this sense, conservative; techno-solutionism is radical. Neither label is a verdict in itself, and the authors argue for being “more open-minded when defining ‘techno-fix’ and not judge, a priori, that they all inevitably will fail.”

Techno-fixes and techno-solutionism compared

Aspect Techno-fixes Techno-solutionism
Technological approach Provides targeted, technical remedies to specific problems Uses technology for broad societal transformation
Scope of change Minimal disruption; maintains existing social norms Significant change; alters social norms and behaviors
Time frame Short-term focus Short-term and long-term focus
Political orientation Conservative; preserves status quo Radical; advocates for systemic change
View of human nature Accepts existing behaviors; bypasses need for change Seeks to modify human behavior and culture
Role of social engineering Avoids extensive social engineering Embraces social engineering through technology
Social resilience May erode resilience by ignoring root causes Aims to strengthen resilience by restructuring society
Examples Carbon capture technology; electric vehicles Geoengineering; AI-driven societal management

Source: Sætra & Selinger (2024), Table 1

Related work

  • Technology and Sustainable Development: The Promise and Pitfalls of Techno-Solutionism (ed.) DOI · Routledge · 2023
  • AI for the Sustainable Development Goals DOI · CRC Press · 2022
  • The AI ESG protocol: Evaluating and disclosing the environment, social, and governance implications of artificial intelligence capabilities, assets, and activities DOI · Sustainable Development · 2023
  • A Framework for Evaluating and Disclosing the ESG Related Impacts of AI with the SDGs DOI · Sustainability · 2021
  • AI in Context and the Sustainable Development Goals: Factoring in the Unsustainability of the Sociotechnical System DOI · Sustainability · 2021
  • Climate change and the political pathways of AI: The technocracy-democracy dilemma in light of artificial intelligence and human agency with Mark Coeckelbergh DOI · Technology in Society · 2023

Further reading

  • Weinberg, A. M. (1966). Can technology replace social engineering? Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 22(10).
  • Morozov, E. (2013). To Save Everything, Click Here: The Folly of Technological Solutionism. PublicAffairs.